Showing posts with label Honesty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Honesty. Show all posts

Feb 8, 2012

Advice From a Third-Year Medical Student, Part II

Editor’s note: Two weeks ago, Lakshman Swamy, an MD/MBA candidate at Boonshoft School of Medicine at Wright State University, shared some advice for other students that he picked up after his third year of medical school. Not just for medical students, the advice touched on humility and the urge to complain. More than 1,000 readers have viewed the post, which you can see here.

Now Lakshman presents Part II of his advice and, again, wants it to be clear that he has made ALL of these mistakes. No one is perfect, he says, but being conscious of these mistakes – and this advice – helped him grow throughout the year. Take it away, Lakshman:
Here are four more great pieces of advice I picked up during my third year in medical school:
1. Don’t Slander. Don't talk badly about other students or, well, anyone. There will be plenty of opportunities to do so because you will see people violating all sorts of rules and you will be infuriated by it. You’ll see other students slinking away and getting days off to study on flimsy excuses – or coincidentally getting all the best cases and the least of the scut work. Ignore it all. Focus on doing the right thing and creating the best image of you. Be an upstanding citizen, ignore what others do, and have a clear idea of your own expectations and stick to them. In doing so, you will stick out and look fantastic – and deservedly so!
2. Put Yourself Together. Don't look like you slept in the hospital even if you actually did. Take care of yourself because you WILL look unprofessional when you don't – and it is very obvious. You will forget things, drop things, make mistakes that affect your team and your patients, and it all ultimately reflects on you.

3. Be a Great Learner. As difficult as it is, don’t be solely focused on tests and grades. You will have a much better time if you try to learn what you need to know because you see it as your own responsibility, rather than trying to pick out the test questions. If you allow yourself to be geared toward that objective goal (the next test, the boards, etc.), you will cement that way of thinking for your entire career. There are two problems I see with this:
  1. You miss out on the depth of the information, and when atypical problems arise, you will be less equipped to deal with them.
  2. You’ll be miserable.
You’ll always be looking for some future challenge that needs to be surpassed, and you won’t be able to relax and experience what is happening right now, and to excel in the moment. I’ve personally missed out on things that I would have been so excited to be a part of because I was more concerned about the upcoming quiz or test.

4. Be an Asset. Be dependable to your team. Run to get data for them and really try to know everything about your patients – just trying will pay off. As Eric Greitens said in his keynote address at the IHI National Forum last December, your strength can come from knowing others rely on you. You'll be amazed at your energy and capacity when you feel like you are an important part of the team. Relish the basic chores you have to do – don't consider them beneath you.

As a student, you’re often the first one to meet a patient and gather their story. Long after you present it, knowing those details can really come in handy and make you look fantastically on top of things. One example: Recently on call, the residents were handed a new patient with a surgery. We were walking to the patient and the residents blanked on some of the details of the case. I had done the H&P, knew everything about that patient, and saved them the hassle of logging into the EMR to get the details. Little things go a long way.


- Lakshman Swamy, MD/MBA Candidate, 2013, Boonshoft School of Medicine at Wright State University

Feb 15, 2010

Being Honest: Ducking Out from Under the Table


My adorable dog, May, has her flaws. Her bark and temper are infamous in our neighborhood. If the toy is not made of rubber, it will become an unrecognizable ball of mush within days. However, when it comes to going out to do her business, May almost never has accidents. On those rare occasions she makes a mistake, she slowly greets us with her head ducked down rather than her normal energy-filled charge when we arrive home.

We understand why these accidents happen. Most medical errors, as discussed in the IOM report, To Err is Human, are a result of poorly designed systems that do not give providers the best chance possible to care for patients in the way that they would like. May's accidents are also systems error. We only find a pool of pee in the house when we leave for a long period of time without allowing her to go out before we leave. May was not being negligent or purposefully filthy; the system she lives in simply does not allow her to successfully avoid these accidents. With these system constraints in mind, we do not blame her, but continue to work on scheduling improvements to prevent future occurrences.



Clinicians never want to intentionally harm their patients and are often emotionally impacted by a mistake. Similarly, as far as we can tell, May deeply regrets her accidents. Since she cannot use words to express her regret, she hides under the dining table and avoids eye contact as we clean up the mess until we say, "It's okay, May." Sometimes, she will even circle the "biohazard" zone slowly, as if admonishing herself. May's actions demonstrate her acknowledgment of the accident and we accept her apology--a courteous exchange that occurs between people all the time.

Medical malpractice is one of the few bipartisan goals of the current health reform battle. However, how to reform this messy process that is hard on all participants (physicians, hospitals, patients and families, and insurers) emotionally and financially is not as clear. Focusing on how to minimize costly lawsuits through caps on financial damages awarded to patients further complicates the fundamental courtesies that should occur when a mistake happens: acknowledgment, understanding, acceptance, and forgiveness.

In a paper published in the NEJM in 2006, then Senators Hilary Clinton and Barack Obama discuss how to improve patient safety and the medical liability climate through open communication between physicians and patients. The paper cites that the most important factor in people's decisions to file lawsuits is not negligence, but ineffective communication between patients and providers: lawsuits occur when "unexpected adverse outcomes are met with a lack of empathy from physicians and a perceived or actual withholding of essential information."



For those of you who are Grey's Anatomy fans (click here to read a Grey's Anatomy Obsession confessional), episode 13 of season 6 titled, "State of Love and Trust," touches specifically on medical liability reform and being honest with patients. A patient, later discovered to have a form of cytochrome P450 that unexpectedly allows her to metabolize anesthesia faster than normal, wakes up from anesthesiology in the middle of her bowel surgery and is traumatized by the violence of surgery and the panicked yelling from the surgical team. Emotionally disturbed by the experience, the patient wishes to press charges against the hospital. Dr. Shepherd, interim Chief of Surgery, is deep in thought about the threat of a lawsuit on his first day as Chief, when Dr. Miranda Bailey talks to him about open communication between physicians and patients in situations of medical error (see clip above). By apologizing to the patient, Dr. Shepherd is acknowledging the mistake and the patient's concerns, is providing the patient with the opportunity to understand and accept the mistake, and is working with the patient to reach an agreement that allows both sides to accept the mistake and attempt to reach forgiveness.

As then Senators Clinton and Obama explain in the paper, open communication allows for improvements in patient safety. The proposed National Medical Error Disclosure and Compensation (MEDiC) Bill was based on model disclosure programs such as those in place at the University of Michigan Health System (Go Blue!) and the Veterans Affairs system. These programs have given both patients and physicians protection while successfully reducing administrative and legal costs for providers, insurers, and hospitals. Surveys from these successful programs have also showed greater trust in and satisfaction with health care providers. On the cost side, the disclosure programs have resulted in the filing of fewer malpractice suits, a reduction in litigation costs, accelerated provision of compensation to patients, and increases in the numbers of patients who are compensated.

It is a remarkable feat that the University of Michigan Health System has reduced litigation costs from $3 million to $1 million in four years with its disclosure program. Though isn't it ironic that at the heart of the solution to such a complex problem are the basic principles of being honest and communicating openly with patients?

Telling patients the truth at times may be harder, but it is the most respectful thing to do. My dog, May, would bark in agreement.